Shaan Slams AI-Generated ‘Saiyaara’ in Kishore Kumar’s Voice as ‘Unfair’—Calls It a Cruel Exploitation of Legacy

Singer Shaan has sharply criticized the growing trend of using AI to recreate the voices of legendary artists. The latest trigger: an AI-generated version of the song Saiyaara modeled to sound like Kishore Kumar, which has rapidly gone viral, drawing nearly as many listens as the original.

He called this practice unethical, even “cruel”, arguing that it cheapens the nuanced artistry of timeless singers and erodes the emotional connection that music traditionally fosters.

AI Nostalgia—Or Cold Rehearsal of Memory?

Shaan’s critique isn’t about the technology itself—it’s about its misuse. Cloning voices of icons like Kishore Kumar to recreate modern tracks strips away the essence of what made their music unforgettable. He warned that such AI attempts distort how new generations perceive these legends.

As Shaan said, “It is wrong to make that song sound like they would sing it today… You can’t AI a person whose singing has been so dynamic.” His call: stop feeding AI-made versions to a generation unfamiliar with the original craft.

Fans Divided—Nostalgia vs. Respect

The AI version of Saiyaara has polarized audiences. Some users marveled it was “more soulful than the original,” while others condemned it as a hollow echo. One commenter noted that while it may mimic style, it lacks the raw life, mischief, and depth of the master’s voice.

The mixed reaction underscores a larger debate: Are AI tributes acts of homage—or outrageous shortcuts that ignore artistic integrity?

Shaan Doesn’t Spare the Audience Either

Shan’s frustration extended beyond creators to consumers. He called the audience “silly” for comparing AI imitations to the genuine article, urging music lovers instead to listen to Kishore Kumar’s authentic renditions—songs that remain timeless precisely because they were born from real emotion, not digital mimicry.

Final Verdict: Innovation or Disrespect?

This controversy isn’t mere resistance to technology—it’s a defense of musical legacy. Shaan’s words are a reminder that legends like Kishore Kumar built their artistry on spontaneity and soulful presence, qualities AI simply cannot replicate.